Annuity vs. Drawdown

Understand the difference, secure your future.

Explore the key differences between annuities and drawdown to help you decide what’s right for your retirement.

As retirement approaches, one of the biggest decisions you’ll make is how to turn your pension pot into income. You can buy an annuity, opt for drawdown, or combine the two.

In this guide, we’ll compare annuity and drawdown, exploring the pros and cons of each, and offer tips about how to choose the right option for you.

 

What’s the difference between annuity and drawdown?

An annuity and drawdown are two different ways of getting income from your pension pot during retirement.

An annuity is a financial product that you buy with some or all of your pension pot. It provides you with a regular, fixed income for the rest of your life.

Drawdown is a way of taking money out of your pension pot, as and when you want, while leaving the rest invested.

Put simply, an annuity gives you guaranteed retirement income, while drawdown gives you flexible retirement income. Remember: you don’t have to choose one or the other, you can split your pot between the two.

It’s important to remember that some choices, such as buying an annuity, cannot usually be changed later. Make sure you understand all risks and guarantees before deciding.

Similarities between annuity and drawdown

There are a few things that apply to both annuity and drawdown:

  • Age: You must be 55 years old to buy an annuity or start drawing down money from your pension pot. (This is set to rise to 57 in April 2028). 
  • Tax-free lump sum: However you take money from your pension, you can take 25% of it tax-free.
  • Tax: The income you get from your pension is taxable.
  • State benefits: The income you receive from your pension is taxable and will be added to your total income for the tax year, which may affect the tax band you fall into.

Annuity pros and cons

  • Guaranteed income: You'll have a regular, predictable income stream, providing financial security and stability.

  • Lack of flexibility: Once your annuity's set up, you can't change or cash in your policy - even if your circumstances change.

  • Limited returns: You might get higher returns from other types of investment if you're comfortable taking more risk.

  • No automatic death benefits: Your income will stop when you die, unless you opt to include death benefits when you buy the annuity. 

  • Peace of mind for life: By turning your pension into an annuity, you’ll always have an income, no matter how long you live.

  • No hidden costs or hassle: All fees are baked into your income calculation, so there’s nothing extra to pay and no investments to manage.

Drawdown pros and cons

  • Growth potential: Your pension stays invested, giving it the chance to grow over time and potentially provide higher returns than a fixed income.

  • Flexibility at your fingertips: You're in control – you can vary your income, take out lump sums or leave money invested.

  • Inheritance planning: Whatever's left in your pension pot can be passed on to your loved ones, free from inheritance tax (although this is set to change in April 2027).

  • Investment risk: The value of your pension can go down as well as up with market movements, affecting your retirement income.

  • Ongoing costs and management: You'll need to pay annual charges and continually monitor your investments, or pay an adviser to do it for you. 

  • Your money could run out: Because withdrawals are flexible and investment values can fall, there’s a risk your pension may not last for the whole of your retirement. 

Choosing the right option for you 

Now that we’ve covered the basics of annuity and drawdown, you can start to think about which is right for you. Do you want the certainty that comes with an annuity, or the flexibility of drawdown? Or would a combination of the two work best for you?

Here are a few things to consider when making your decision:

  • Health and family history: If long life runs in your family, guaranteed income could be particularly valuable throughout your retirement. 
  • Other income sources: State pension, other pensions or savings will affect how much certainty or flexibility you need from this pot. 
  • Comfort with risk: Some people sleep soundly with investments that fluctuate, while others prefer knowing exactly what's coming in each month. 
  • Spending patterns: Consider whether your expenses will stay fairly steady or if you'll need larger sums for travel, home improvements or helping family. 
  • Loved ones: Leaving something behind might be important to you, or you may prefer to maximise your income. 
  • Financial confidence: You might be happy managing investments and making withdrawal decisions, or want a hands-off approach.

Ready to take the next step?

Speaking to an expert can help you turn all this information into a decision that works for you. 

Get free guidance 
If you’re 50 or over, you can book a free Pension Wise appointment with a pension specialist at Money Helper.  
Visit Money Helper 

Find a financial adviser 
Read our guide to finding the right financial adviser, and tips for your first meeting.  
Learn more about financial advisers 

 

Learn more about annuities

What is an annuity?

Introducing annuities: what they are, how they work and key things to consider.

Read more

Types of annuity

Your guide to understanding the different annuity options and finding the right fit for your needs.

Read more

Annuity rates

Read on to find out what annuity rates are, the factors that influence them and how to get the best rate for your circumstances.

Read more

Get in touch

Have questions? Our friendly team is here to chat through your options. 

Call us on 0345 606 0708or +44 1707 651 122 
(Monday – Friday 9am to 5pm) 

Or email Customer.Services@canadalife.co.uk 

6269660 0726